Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>> This wasn’t intended as any sort of super-duper hot take, and I pared the post down to avoid having too much of an attack surface.

It is intended to shame Republicans. What other possible reason is there to tie death rates to political party? So yes it was a hot take. You planted a lightning rod. Making something like vaccination a political issue does everyone a disservice.



While I’m a democrat, I don’t believe republicans or democrats are inherently better people, or that their overarching ideologies are inherently better. In fact I am a strong believer that absolute power corrupts absolutely, and neither republicans or democrats should win it all.

That said, certain Republicans should very much feel shame about the fear mongering behind the vaccine. It isn’t automatically a hot take or a lightning rod to use statistical analyses to suggest that systemic fear mongering against a vaccine that has a powerful effect would lead to excess death.

The vaccine long ago became a political issue, but the real world need for people to take it doesn’t go away because of that.


>I don’t believe republicans or democrats are inherently better people

Then you aren't paying attention to what the Republican party stands for. Moral relativism has limits, and the Republican party now regularly acts with malice.


> Making something like vaccination a political issue does everyone a disservice.

You can pin a lot on nate silver, but vaccination as a political issue is a thing he's studying, not a thing he caused.


It certainly did a disservice to the people who died because their politics convinced them that the vaccine was worse than the disease.


The idea that nobody should ever point that fact out seems crazy to me. We should be using this as an example when teaching critical thinking skills to kids in schools so that they know not to let political ideology and lies manipulate them into the grave.


Yeah, let's not make this political. /s


It also shames Democrats to an extent because they were more likely to support restrictions before the vaccines.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: